Skip to main content
Industry Insights

How Insurance Agencies Can Meet Changing Client Expectations

By September 11, 2025No Comments
Blog - Meet Client Expectations

Insurance is and always has been an industry that has people at the center of it—especially when it comes to independent insurance agencies.

That’s why client communication is as important as ever. Gone are the days of just walking to your insurance agent’s office. Now, people expect to handle the process of buying, managing, and renewing insurance coverage digitally. As an industry, independent insurance agencies need to adapt to these changes in communication preferences.

According to a study run by Smart Communications, 39% of people prefer online and mobile-friendly experiences to make account or policy changes to their insurance policies. (Source: Smart Communications)

This number is only going to rise as technology continues to evolve and the landscape of the industry adapts. Insurance agencies have the ability to take control of this trend and benefit from it.


Meeting and exceeding client communication expectations.

First, it’s important to understand exactly what client preferences are trending toward, as well as the existing technology and tools out there to make transitions realistic for any agency. Let’s break this down into two categories: inbound and outbound client communications.

Inbound client communications cover a variety of methods clients have available to them in order to contact their agency. Outbound client communications include the ways agents, CSRs, and insurance professionals have at their disposal to contact clients and leads. Both inbound and outbound client communication are equally important, and communication in general is a make-or-break situation for many clients.

In fact, 66% of insureds say they would switch insurance providers if their communications did not meet their expectations (Source: Smart Communications).

That’s a staggering number, and this is precisely why prioritizing communications is more important than ever for insurance agencies to grow and retain a book of business.

How can insurance agencies improve inbound client communications?

Inbound client communications cover all the bases of how insureds can reach their agency. Most insurance agencies have an office, and even those that don’t, a vast majority will have both a dedicated phone number and email address.

Now, let’s pinpoint some potential weak points based on what clients expect their insurance agency to have in place for them.

1. Self-service forms are a must for insurance agencies.

In this digital-first world that we live in, people are more likely to reach for their phone not to call their agent, but rather, to engage with their insurance agency online. Clients want to be able to visit their insurance agency’s website to access a client portal login and submit a simple form to get a quote, report a claim, adjust their policy, or simply get in contact with their agent.

To meet client expectations, insurance agencies need to have this basic, but crucial form of communication to allow clients to feel more in control of their coverage and the convenience of making requests on their schedule, not just during office hours.

Handling these form submissions and requests can be done at any size agency through a variety of website forms or client portal solutions, and is an essential part of their tech stack.

With this in mind, you need to ask yourself: Does your insurance agency have the self-service options your clients are asking for? Or do you have some work to do?

We’ll use our Forge insurance website platform as an example to show you how other insurance agencies are using forms and client portal integrations to give clients what they’re looking for. Agencies using Forge have access to self-service options, including:

  • Request Quote and Contact Us Forms: Simplifies client inquiries and quote requests with easy-to-use forms, ensuring quick responses and efficient follow-up.
  • Report a Claim Form: Streamlines the claim reporting process with a straightforward form that allows clients to submit claims and attach necessary documents easily.
  • Request Certificate and Auto ID Card Forms: Facilitates the quick and secure request of essential documents like insurance certificates and auto ID cards, enhancing client convenience.
  • Policy Change and Review Forms: Offers clients a simple way to request policy changes or reviews, ensuring their coverage is always up-to-date and tailored to their needs.
  • Insurance Carrier Pages with Links for Payments or Claims: Provides direct access to insurance carrier pages for payments and claims, simplifying navigation and enhancing the client experience.

This encompasses what the majority of insurance agencies will need, from P&C lines and beyond. If you have a Forge insurance website or are interested, you’ll have everything you need set up and ready for your clients to use. In addition, there are email notifications built in, so you’ll never miss a form submission, meaning you can respond even faster to requests from clients and prospects alike.

Having a self-service system like Forge is essential for your business so you can stay ahead in the digital-first landscape, while establishing trust and credibility with your clients. Because at the end of the day, the more ways that people can interact with your business online—the better—as it’s where most people will look to interact with you.

2. Live chat to reach out to insurance agencies with ultimate convenience.

Some clients prefer phone calls. Many more prefer having the option to start a live chat conversation with an insurance agency. It’s all about convenience at the end of the day. Live chat encourages engagement from the clients and shows the credibility of an agency that is able to reply in real time to help out a client or prospect.

Live chat features come in many flavors, but the primary application is the ability to have team members at an agency be responsible for checking and responding to live chat sessions with clients, which are typically less time-intensive or involved than an office visit or lengthy phone call in many instances—especially in handling those quick requests.

An insurance agency with live chat as an option shows that they are willing to meet clients where they are, and provides the opportunity to have more engagement and therefore positive experiences, which lead directly to loyalty, positive reviews, and retention.

The good news is, this makes it even easier for your team to stay connected and save more time communicating back and forth with clients. For example, if someone chats in with either a simple question or request, because they would be using live chat on your website, you can easily direct them to a relevant page or form on your website, instead of having to do extra steps yourself on their behalf.

If your website does not currently have a live chat feature, you should consider adding it, as the technology has advanced over the years to make it easier for your agency and your clients to use.

For example, our Forge insurance website platform is compatible with our Business Texting feature, which can be added to not just enable one-to-one text messaging with your clients. On top of that, you can add live Web Chat to your website through this system, which includes:

  • Two-Way Communication: Allows for real-time, two-way communication with clients directly through text messaging.
  • Smart Notifications: Alerts you to incoming messages, ensuring no client communication is missed.
  • Automation Features: Enables automated responses during off-hours to set the right follow-up expectations with your clients.
  • Real-Time Interaction: Provides instant communication with clients visiting your website, offering immediate assistance and support.

These features cover the necessary communication elements that give your clients what they need, and empower your agency to accommodate those needs by simplifying the live chat experience on both sides. As a final takeaway for live chat, even if your agency prefers phone calls and in-person visits, live chat is another way to build connections with clients, make them feel heard, and, most importantly, make your business as accessible as possible to reach.

3. Text messaging for reminders and quick conversations can be a game-changer for insurance agencies.

Most people have cell phones, and as they have become more prevalent in this day and age, their integration into businesses has been par for the course over the last few years. Insurance agencies have an opportunity to leverage text messaging with their clients in more ways than one. But when it comes to inbound client communications, having a number someone can text means they feel taken care of at all times.

The technology for business texting solutions has evolved over time, with options for auto-responders during off hours, smart notifications to not miss a text from a client, and not to mention automation to reach back out to clients or remind them of renewals and changes.

We mentioned our Business Texting feature above, and the same level of interaction with live chat and texting is there. Here’s how our solution works to enable your agency to simplify communications via text message:

  • Easy Conversations: Chat back and forth with clients effortlessly. It’s like texting a friend—quick and straightforward.
  • Stay Notified: Get notified when clients text you, so you’re always ready to respond and keep them happy.
  • Hands-Free Replies: Set up automatic replies for when you’re out of the office. This way, clients know you’ll get back to them soon.

With Business Texting, you’re not just keeping up with the times—you’re making it easier for clients to stay in touch and feel valued. In addition, the best part is, you are proving to your clients that you are always there for them. With a tool like Business Texting, you can give clients a number they can text anytime, making them feel cared for, building trust and loyalty.

How can insurance agencies improve outbound client communications?

When reaching out to clients with outbound communications (meaning an agency reaching out to their client base), whether it’s for the purpose of updating someone on a policy or for marketing purposes, the applications go hand in hand.

Let’s say an insurance agency has the core foundation in place for inbound communications: a website, self-service forms, live chat, and business text messaging. They can focus in on each of those areas of communication to connect with clients directly and therefore increase engagement, loyalty, and retention.

1. Leverage email automation to communicate with clients more efficiently.

Insurance agencies need to keep up with client expectations for quick and efficient communication. Clients want timely updates and seamless interactions without having to wait for office hours. Automation platforms empower agencies to streamline their communication efforts across multiple channels—relieving the workload for agents, CSRs, and insurance professionals.

With an email marketing platform, such as Fuse marketing automation, you can set up automated emails to send marketing materials, policy updates, and reminders at the right time.

Using these automation tools, your agency can provide the fast, efficient service clients expect, making them feel valued and connected at all times. Here are some examples of what our Fuse marketing automation platform provides in terms of automating email communications, which include must-have features for any insurance agency:

  • Automated Email Campaigns: Send targeted emails based on client behavior and preferences, keeping your communication personalized and effective.
  • Behavior-Triggered Emails: Automatically reach out to clients based on their interactions with your content, ensuring timely follow-ups and increased engagement.
  • Segmentation and Personalization: Use advanced segmentation to tailor your messages for different client groups, enhancing the relevance and impact of your communications.
  • Performance Analytics: Gain insights into email performance with detailed analytics, allowing you to refine your strategies and maximize engagement.
  • Drip Campaigns: Create a series of automated emails to nurture leads over time, building relationships and guiding clients through their decision-making process.

Is your agency equipped with the automation tools needed to meet client expectations? Or is there room for improvement? Explore how Fuse can enhance your agency’s communication strategy, making it easier to connect with clients and meet their needs efficiently. With Fuse, you can schedule emails to reach clients when they’re most likely to engage, ensuring your messages are both timely and relevant.

2. Create video content that engages clients.

Video content is rapidly becoming a cornerstone of effective communication. For insurance agencies, leveraging video for outbound communications can significantly enhance client engagement and understanding.

Incorporating video into your communication strategy adds a personal touch that written content often lacks. It allows you to share complex information about policies and coverage options clearly and concisely, making it easier for clients to grasp the details of their insurance. This is especially true during key points of a client’s journey with your agency, especially around renewal time.

Clients appreciate when their agency goes the extra mile to ensure they understand their policies. Video proposals can break down the intricacies of coverage options, renewal processes, and policy changes, offering a visual and engaging way to communicate essential information.

Using our own Forge Video Proposals feature as an example, your agency can create personalized video messages tailored to individual client needs. Here’s how this tool can transform your communication:

  • Personalized Messaging: Deliver customized video proposals that address specific client queries, making them feel valued and understood.
  • Easy Sharing: Send video proposals via email, allowing clients to access and review the information at their convenience.
  • Track Engagement: Monitor how clients interact with your videos, gaining insights into their preferences and interests to tailor future communications.

Video proposals not only enhance understanding but also build trust and loyalty by demonstrating your commitment to client satisfaction. If your agency hasn’t yet embraced video, consider integrating Forge Video Proposals to stay ahead in the digital-first world.

3. Keep your clients informed through social media.

Social media platforms are vital tools for insurance agencies to communicate important updates and build trust with clients. Sharing timely content helps keep clients informed and engaged, fostering a strong relationship between them and your agency.

Clients expect immediate access to information. And one place where they are looking and spending time—social media platforms.

Social media allows you to share updates about office closures, local natural disasters, or changes in coverage quickly and efficiently. And the best part is, your clients are already on these platforms and can easily stay informed. Beyond updates, social media is a platform for educating clients about insurance basics, coverage options, and industry trends.

By providing valuable information, you position your agency as a trusted advisor and resource.

Let’s use our Social Media add-on as an example to walk through how to properly leverage technology to maximize your agency’s social media prowess. Our platform empowers agencies to streamline their efforts and maximize impact. Here’s how it can help:

  • Content Scheduling: Plan and schedule posts in advance, ensuring consistent and timely communication with your audience.
  • Engagement Analytics: Track how your content performs, gaining insights into what resonates with clients to refine your strategy.
  • Integrated Campaigns: Align social media efforts with other marketing initiatives, enhancing reach and effectiveness.

By leveraging social media effectively, your agency can maintain open lines of communication, build trust, and demonstrate your commitment to client service. If you’re not fully utilizing social media, consider the Social Media add-on to enhance your communication strategy and connect with clients in meaningful ways.

Be open to change and adapt to new technologies.

In a rapidly evolving industry like insurance, staying flexible and open to change is crucial. Embracing new technologies can significantly enhance your agency’s efficiency and client satisfaction.

By staying ahead of technological trends, you not only meet client expectations but also gain a competitive edge.

Whether it’s integrating new communication tools or adopting innovative marketing strategies, being adaptable ensures your agency remains relevant and successful in a retention-focused industry. Encourage your team to explore and experiment with new tools, fostering a culture of innovation and growth.

1. Adopt email automation into everyday operations.

Automation is more than just a time-saver; it’s a strategic tool that can transform how your agency operates.

By automating routine tasks like sending emails, updating client records, or managing policy renewals, you free up valuable time for your team to focus on high-impact activities.

This shift not only boosts productivity but also enhances client interactions by ensuring timely and consistent communication.

Evaluate your current processes to identify areas where automation can be implemented, and invest in platforms like Fuse to streamline operations and improve client engagement.

2. Improve accessibility with self-service website forms.

Clients expect convenience and control over their interactions with service providers.

Offering self-service options through website forms and client portals empowers clients to manage their policies, request quotes, or report claims at their convenience.

This autonomy not only enhances client satisfaction but also reduces the workload on your staff. Ensure your website is equipped with user-friendly forms and portals, and regularly update these tools to meet evolving client needs.

By providing easy access to self-service options, you demonstrate your commitment to client-centric service and modernize your agency’s operations.

3. Leverage live chat features on websites.

Live chat is a powerful tool for engaging clients in real-time, offering immediate assistance and building stronger relationships. Unlike traditional communication methods, live chat provides a quick and convenient way for clients to get answers to their questions without lengthy phone calls or office visits.

Implementing live chat on your website shows clients that you value their time and are ready to meet them where they are.

Ensure your team is trained to handle live chat interactions effectively, and consider integrating easy-to-use live chat features to manage basic inquiries, freeing up your team to focus on more complex client needs.

4. Provide text messaging options.

Text messaging is an essential communication channel that offers immediacy and convenience for both clients and agencies. By providing a text messaging option, you allow clients to reach out with quick questions or requests, enhancing their overall experience. Business Texting can also be used for sending reminders, updates, or personalized messages, keeping clients informed and engaged.

Implement smart notifications and automated responses to ensure timely follow-ups, and use this channel to build trust and loyalty with your clients.

Embrace text messaging as part of your communication strategy to stay connected and responsive to client needs.

5. Incorporate video content into client communications.

Video content is rapidly becoming a preferred medium for client communication due to its ability to convey complex information in an engaging and easily digestible format.

By incorporating video into your communication strategy, you can provide clients with personalized messages that enhance their understanding of policies, coverage options, and agency updates.

Video proposals can offer a visual and personal touch that written content often lacks, fostering a stronger connection with clients. Consider using platforms like Forge to create and share video content that addresses client queries and educates them about their insurance needs.

This approach not only builds trust and credibility but also differentiates your agency in a competitive market.

6. Utilize social media for timely and relevant client engagement.

Social media platforms are invaluable tools for keeping clients informed and engaged. By sharing timely content such as office closures, local news, industry trends, and educational materials, you position your agency as a trusted resource and community partner.

Social media allows for immediate communication and feedback, enabling you to address client concerns and questions quickly.

Utilize the Social Media add-on to schedule posts, track engagement, and integrate your efforts with other marketing campaigns. By maintaining an active and responsive social media presence, you can build stronger relationships with clients, enhance your agency’s visibility, and demonstrate your commitment to providing valuable information and support.


Want to learn more?

If you’re ready to take the next step, our complete insurance marketing platform offers the tools and features your agency needs to stand out and succeed.

From marketing automation that keeps you connected with clients and boosts retention, to insurance websites designed to drive growth, and a suite of marketing tools to meet your needs, Agency Revolution is everything you need after your AMS.

Learn All About Our Complete Insurance Agency Marketing Platform